The Goth Detective [ARTICLE]

A Dark Gem Created by Accident

Agent Aloysius Pendergast

Agent Aloysius Pendergast (from the fan fiction illustration “Bros” by illustrator Jeff Zachowski.)

When you list off great Goth literary characters in both book and film, it’s easy to focus on the usual Gothic who’s who: Anne Rice’s LeStat (of The Vampire Chronicles), the Wachowski’s Neo (of The Matrix), Mary Shelley’s Doctor Frankenstein (of Frankenstein), Tim Burton’s Jack Skellington (of The Nightmare Before Christmas), or almost any protagonist of Edgar Allen Poe. However, there is another literary character that easily deserves to join the Gothic pantheon: Agent Aloysius Pendergast.

The personality of Pendergast might be summed up as a modern, Gothic take on Sherlock Holmes, but, that’s only half true, because Holmes had no use for people…only the solving of cases. However, much like Michael Weston of Burn Notice and Neal Caffrey in White Collar, Pendergast is as much a social engineer as an erudite sleuth. (So much so that half the joy I’ve found in reading the books has been the fact that you don’t know what Pendergast will say next and you vicariously wish you could get away with saying the things he does. This is no more true than in the most Gothic of his novels, Still Life with Crows. More on that later.) Along with Sherlock Holmes, Neal Caffrey, and Michael Weston, the character is spiced with generous doses of Dexter (from Showtime’s Dexter), Data (from Star Trek: the Next Generation), and Dream (from Sandman).

Described as looking and dressing like “an albino undertaker,” the pale-skinned and pale-eyed Pendergast is a New Orleans FBI agent who comes from enough family money that he is able to afford to wear exquisite black suits from Europe, have an entire floor of a Gothic apartment building in NYC to himself, and be conveyed in a chauffeured Rolls Royce to crime scenes.

To go along with this familial largesse is enough family sin that Pendergast became an agent out of a compulsion to right what wrongs he can as a form of penance. Of course, because of his financial resources (and his past successes), he is able to pick and choose the cases he chooses to associate with. The cases that hit his radar most often are killings of supernatural appearance and those having to do with dark sociopathy.

Writers' spat between Preston & Child provided the perfect storm for Pendergast.

A writers’ spat between Preston & Child provided the perfect Frankenstein storm to bring the enigmatic Agent Aloysius Pendergast to life.

Douglas Preston & Lincoln Child, the co-authors of the series, didn’t actually intend to create the Pendergast character originally. Instead, as they worked on the flagship book, Relic–which introduced a female protagonist named Margo Green–they had a fight about two police officers Preston had created. Child complained that they were virtually identical and wouldn’t it be better if one was “a fish out of water.” The attack on his creativity rankled Preston who snarked back with, “What? Like an albino from New Orleans?” To which Child responded, “An albino from New Orleans…yeah, I think we could work with that.” (The authors are quick to point out that the character is “not actually albino…just very, very pale.“)*

Remembering the surreal birth of the sleuth who has since been in 12 novels (the most recent of which being Two Graves, which was released in December), Child states that it was like:

“[Pendergast] stepped up and shook our hands, a little disdainfully, and said, ‘I will be your character, thank you.’ No other character we’ve invented materialized so suddenly and so completely.”

So, if your interested in getting into the Pendergast series and its dark J.J.-Abrams-like backstories, where do you start? Because Pendergast was an add-on character in his first two books, those books actually read most like prequels to the Pendergast saga. They’re a great way to get some interesting backstory on a number of characters which will continue to show up throughout series, but they’re not the best representation of the series for a newcomer, who will make up their mind as to “should I stay or I should I go” (to quote the Clash) within a book or two.

Cabinet of Curiosities is the ideal book to start your exploration of Aloysius Pendergast.

Cabinet of Curiosities is the ideal book to start your exploration of Aloysius Pendergast.

As such, you really need to start with The Cabinet of Curiosities which kicks off with Pendergast firmly in the driver’s seat (which you’ll quickly find is where he belongs) in a New York City investigation into the skeletons in the closet of a 100 year old serial killer. If you enjoy that one then the follow up, Still Life with Crows, will rock your socks off as the often city dwelling Pendergast is forced to go to a backwoods Kansas town, adopting the town’s only Goth girl as his protégé and impulsive sidekick. For everyone who’s been a victim of small minded bigotry, the brilliant demeanor of Pendergast and the things he pops off with to those who are too full of themselves will make you get up and cheer.

And, if you prefer to listen to audio books, the Pendergast series is fully represented. While some other voice talents have helped bring the early series to life, it is most fully embodied in later books by the amazingly talented Rene Auberjonois (Deep Space Nine, Soul Reaver 2, Benson), whose ability with fine Southern gentry makes his presentations riveting! (He even looks fairly like Pendergast.)

Unfortunately, right now, there are no plans to make the Pendergast series into a film. I say the Pendergast series because, when Relic was made into a feature film by Paramount in 1997, in a choice even more freakish than Bruce Lee being passed over in favor of David Carradine for the lead in Kung Fu, Pendergast’s character was actually deleted.

According to a December interview with Preston & Child in the TulsaWorld Scene, Child stated about the film:

“Pendergast was in the early version of the ‘Relic’ script, but he didn’t make the final screenplay…He was probably just too hard to write, not to mention cast.”

“Paramount still controls his character rights in terms of film, and we keep hoping that they will show interest in making a Pendergast movie. We have no idea who to cast.”

As far as casting, for my money, Daniel Craig with his watery, silver-blue eyes would be a great choice so long as he could do the accent and provided his blonde locks got the full Game of Thrones’ Dragonborn-silverhair treatment.

Of course, if the Paramount controls of Pendergast only exist in relation to feature films, then following the pattern of the UK’s Sherlock–a modernized television adaptation of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s seminal novels–might hold the key to a cross-media adaptation. After all, the cutting edge style of Sherlock could easily be adapted for the Pendergast series (which often has a similar two person chemistry). Considering that Viacom (who owns Paramount Pictures) doesn’t own any television networks which would be particularly appropriate for something like a Pendergast show—which would flourish on channels like AMC, USA, or even SyFy—it’s indeed possible that the authors still have the rights for television. If so, hopefully AMC will make a bid, as we could all use a high quality adaptation of Pendergast and AMC could use another show that is regularly winning Emmies! 

Author: JT Hanke

J.T. Hanke is the founder and current editor-in-chief of DarkestGoth Magazine. Founded in 2012, DGM took a break from publishing at the height of the pandemic so that all the staff could work through their own issues, but was able to return in January of 2023.

Share This Post On


  1. I love the idea of a cable show!

    Post a Reply
  2. I’ve read the entire series and am a die-hard fan of Lincoln & Child and, of course, Agent Pendergast. Great reading!

    Post a Reply
  3. Great recognition of Pendergast and the guys! Preston and Child my favorite authors along with the great Stephen King.

    Post a Reply
  4. Makes me want to read more about this character. Seems like a character I’d enjoy.

    Post a Reply
  5. fabulous article… about a fabulous character. Casting Pendergast – now, that will be a challenge! Someone tall, lithe, elegant and probably unknown. Pendergast is iconic to all those that love his character – he is the next type of “Bond, James Bond” figure, meaning the actor who plays this part will become the image – In my opinion, Anne Rice’s “Lestat” was completely ruined by the casting – notice that there have been no follow-up movies, and her books-into-movies for the original vampires that BE has never continued, with good reason. Nothing ruins a good story faster than the wrong actor playing the part!

    Post a Reply
  6. I love these novels and I am an oil portrait painter. The above is NOT the vision I have of Pendergast. I am currrently working on an oil of Penumbra, Tristrum, Aloysius and a visitor which I am simply naming ‘Penumbra’. I will share it with the authors and it is MINE alone. I love his character. I can’t wait for the Alban Series. I have listened to Two Graves until I have it memorized! Crack on, gentleman! Can’t wait for the next one!

    Post a Reply
    • That’s actually rather an interesting idea. As each person has such a unique vision, it would be interesting to see what different fans came up with! I’ll ask the authors if they’d be interested in maybe a fan visualization push or contest for Pendergast!

      Post a Reply
  7. My first encounter with the magnificent Pendergast was in “The Cabinet of Curiosities” (excellent advice for readers, Mr. Hanke). I’ve been hooked ever since. I was outraged by the omission of the Pendergast character in the film version of Relic. I would love to see a series, but on an uncensored commercial-free channel, like HBO. Most of the cable channels distract the viewer with large pop-up ads and commercial breaks in the worst places.

    Post a Reply
  8. Reading about this makes me want to find “The cabinet of Curiosities”….

    Post a Reply
    • Click on the Link in the article and it takes you to a discounted copy on Amazon. If you want to try before you buy, most libraries have them in both print and audio versions. And if they’re temporarily out, they are often willing to ship them to you from other libraries. (That’s what I did when I first got started on the series. Once I realized how good they were, I went through and bought them all.)

      Post a Reply
  9. Thank you for such a great article! Pendergast is truly an incredible character and one that has performed perfectly throughout his various books. I first discovered him when reading “The Relic” many years ago in middle school and have been a fan of Douglas Preston and Lincoln Child’s solo and combined efforts ever since. They were probably the main reason I became a writer. It was their style of writing that led me to create and publish the dark thriller “Moonlit Nights”. Keep up the wonderful articles Jeremy Hanke!

    Post a Reply


  1. Dancing on Graves with Preston & Child, Pt. 1 [INTERVIEW] | DarkestGoth Magazine - [...] been following DGM’s coverage of the Pendergast saga, then you’ve doubtless read our article: The Goth Detective. Co-Authors Douglas…
  2. The Lost Island [BOOK REVIEW] | DarkestGoth Magazine - […] are most well known for their creation of the Agent Pendergast novels, which we’ve written articles on here at…

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.